Atmosphere: The space gives off that cozy neighborhood vibe, with the exposed brick walls and lack of tablecloths. There's an open kitchen towards the rear of the restaurant, but the only thing I could really get a look at was the plating of some desserts. The lighting is a bit dim for my taste, but that appears to be the norm in the West Village.
Service: It seems like they have a script and the servers stick to it. Can't really complain.
Food:
Dinner starts off with two pieces of puffed naan-like bread, but with a dip reminiscent of the curry that I would eat with roti canai. A bread service that tries to provide more flavor than just bread with butter and salt is a winner in my book.
DUCK SUNG CHOY BAOThis was the first official duck course of the meal. The hoisin sauce, vegetables, and lettuce wrap allowed us to begin tasting duck but in a refreshing bite. A good starter.
DUCK BUNSIn addition to using duck meat, the buns distinguished themselves from other popular pork buns around the city by being fried. I liked the fried texture, which reminded me of fried mantou as dessert/dim sum, especially with the sweet mayo-like sauce.
DUCK MEATBALLSThere is nothing at all Asian about this dish except for the forced use of paneer as the cheese. The meatballs themselves were decent, and packed rather tightly. The tomato sauce had enough acidity, though it did still have sweetness in addition to that from the accompanying squash.
Someone from the kitchen came by to show us the whole duck prepared two ways. I didn't get all of the descriptions, but one had some kind of glaze and the other was wrapped in lotus leaf before both went into their brick oven.
EIGHT TREASURE STICKY RICEThe accompanying side dish for our main course exceeded my expectations. It wasn't too sticky or too sweet, and worked well for eating with the duck.
DUCK TWO WAYSOur main course, served with seasonal greens, which were Chinese broccoli that night. The vegetables were good and provided a much needed crunch, as neither preparation had crispy skin. The meat on the legs fell off the bone and were a comforting mass of rendered fat and tender flesh. The breast however, was not as successful, in my opinion. As the skin wasn't crispy and the fat wasn't rendered enough, the piece of skin and fat attached to the meat was superfluous, and felt awkward texturally as a whole.
DUCK BROTHUsually the course between the main entree and the dessert serves as a bridge from savory to sweet. In this case, they gave us what was probably the most savory course of the night, a rich, concentrated duck broth with a good amount of molten duck fat at the top.
DUCK A LA PLUMThe roast duck ice cream with star anise poached plum was the big winner of the night. It was the most interesting combination of flavors and textures of the night, and served as a very comforting end to a big meal.
A plum cocktail shooter and five spice cookies came with the dessert and matched perfectly with the flavors of the ice cream.The only dish that really stood out for me was the duck ice cream, as something that I would go there just to have. While some of the dishes were fine on their own, the composition of the meal was just too one-note for my taste. Sweetness was featured in every course except the broth, making its strongest appearance in the main entree. If they kept the preparation of the legs the same but changed the breast preparation to something completely savory with crispy skin, I think the meal as a whole would benefit greatly. Overall, it's still a great value for $65+t/t per person given the neighborhood and especially if you like duck.
